Is the Enthusiasm for Democracy Sustainable?

Because of the ongoing revolutions in the MENA region, Pew Research attempts to distill on the sustainability of enthusiasm for democracy using past experiences.

In a recent study, using the East Europe’s experience, the Pew Research finds that enthusiasm for democracy has declined.

Pew Research’s James Bell writes,

These findings do not mean that East Europeans were inclined to abandon democracy. Publics across the region broadly endorsed the demise of communism. Rather these opinions point to the gap between what East Europeans hoped for and what they perceived in terms of political change. On one hand, East Europeans generally agreed that two decades of political and economic change had disproportionately benefited business owners and politicians, rather than ordinary people. On the other, many East Europeans felt democratization had yet to match expectations. In 2009, the median percentage in each country who said a fair judiciary, multiparty elections, uncensored media, freedom of religion, freedom of speech and civilian control of the military were very important significantly exceeded the median percentage who claimed these institutions described their country very well.

Reflecting on Mr. Bell’s statement, the issue isn’t about the loss of interest on democracy but rather the mismatch between people’s expectations on their definition or their concept of democracy and that of economic prosperity.

So when economic distribution has had “disproportionately benefited business owners and politicians” this only means that the political economic framework has segued from communism to one of crony capitalism based on a social democratic form of governance.

Furthermore, expectations for more freedom have not been met perhaps due to the same reasons.

This phenomenon seems to reflect on the Philippines too. After two People Power revolts, Filipinos have still been waiting for Godot.

Filipinos appear to be impassioned on democracy as demonstrated by the eagerness to vote. However eventually they get frustrated again. That’s because their expectations clashes with the reality: Filipinos largely see economic salvation from political distribution rather than from their own efforts.

We, Filipinos, seem to have little understanding that political distribution is a zero sum game (one gains the other losses, i.e. picking on Pedro’s pocket and giving to Mario), while economic distribution is a net value added.

Yet this doesn’t mean that any nation aspiring for democracy isn’t fit for it. It takes time for people to learn, understand and embrace the concept of economic freedom and civil liberties as this is a process of discovery.

And it all starts with the “right” education.