How Inflationism Spurred Singapore’s Labor Protectionism

In August of 2012, I wrote about Singapore’s “gradual descent into the welfare state” as politicians divert the public’s attention by blaming symptoms of bubbles (zooming property prices and wage inflation) on immigrants to justify increased taxes for social spending.

Singapore’s homegrown bubbles as seen via record home prices (as of August) has been fueled by massive credit expansion or the zooming loans to the private sector.

This has been enabled and facilitated by the central bank’s accrued efforts to suppress the domestic currency, the Singaporean Dollar, from rising by accumulating enormous foreign exchange reserves by printing lots of domestic currency, thereby the easy money environment.  And due to such exchange rate management measures, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) even posted a $10.2 loss last year.

These bubble activities by the MAS have only amplified on the growing nationalism where this year the ruling party lost due to increasing populist clamor for immigration curbs.

Singapore’s housing index has already surpassed the pre-Asian crisis highs. This shows why the recent “FED taper” turmoil in May-June materially affected Singapore’s financial markets.

Now to Singapore’s labor protectionism, from Bloomberg:

Singapore will widen foreign-worker curbs to professional jobs as the government clamps down on companies that hire overseas talent at the expense of citizens, stepping up efforts to counter a backlash against immigration.

The Southeast Asian nation said yesterday it will set up a job bank where companies are required to advertise positions to Singaporeans before applying for so-called employment passes for foreign professionals. The unprecedented policy will target jobs that currently pay at least S$3,000 ($2,400) a month.

“There are concerns among Singaporeans, which I think is fair, and so it’s timely for us to introduce this,” Acting Manpower Minister Tan Chuan-Jin said in a Bloomberg Television interview yesterday. “There are Singaporeans out there, well-skilled and capable, who are looking for jobs and I think this step would actually facilitate that process.”

The country is persisting with a four-year campaign to reduce its reliance on foreign workers, after years of open immigration policy led to voter discontent over increased competition for housing, jobs and education. The move has led to a labor shortage and pushed up wages, prompting some companies to seek cheaper locations…

Singapore will also raise the minimum pay for employment-pass holders by 10 percent to S$3,300 a month in January, the Ministry of Manpower said in a statement yesterday. The job bank will be set up by mid-2014, it said. Companies with 25 or fewer employees will be exempt from the new rules, as well as jobs that pay a fixed monthly salary of S$12,000 or more, the ministry said.

Singapore’s declining economic freedom and the rise of economic nationalism as a consequence of the global and Singapore’s easy money regime is a sad development especially that I have regards for the country. 

Yet one thing leads to another. Since property bubbles and wage inflation are symptoms, policies that address symptoms means the disease won’t be cured. And once the labor-immigration controls fail to stem her bubbles and the perceived political inequalities, the government of Singapore will resort to even more controls or interventions in other areas (perhaps capital and exchange controls, trade, social mobility as the above, deeper wage and labor controls and more), that would mean lesser prosperity for Singaporeans.

And growing politicization of an economy will lead to more social tensions as various parties compete to use government ‘coercive’ machinery as means to promote their self-interests through the repression of the interests of the others. So as economic freedom declines, economic fascism and or cronyism increases.

Inflationism and social controls or political economic interventionism have always been intertwined. As the great Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises warned (On The Manipulation of Money and Credit)

Inflationism, however, is not an isolated phenomenon. It is only one piece in the total framework of politico-economic and socio-philosophical ideas of our time. Just as the sound money policy of gold standard advocates went hand in hand with liberalism, free trade, capitalism and peace, so is inflationism part and parcel of imperialism, militarism, protectionism, statism and socialism