Quote of the Day: The Virtues of Stock Market Speculation

But the speculator’s actions have conferred definite services to the community. He has smoothed out the jumps in Acme’s share price. By buying the undervalued stock, he has put upward pressure on the price. (Likewise, if he short sells an overvalued stock, he puts downward pressure on the price.) Rather than Acme’s stock jumping from $10 to $20 when war breaks out, it jumps only from $13 to $20, because (in our example) the speculator’s heavy buying had already closed 30% of the gap.

By reducing stock price volatility, speculators take some of the risk out of holding stocks. For example, it’s not necessarily true that the person who sold early to the speculator at $11 “lost” $9 to the wily profiteer. It’s entirely possible that the person needed to sell his holdings of Acme because he had lost his job or because his kid’s tuition went up again. Thus, the speculator has actually made this person — who had planned to sell even if Acme remained at $10 — richer.

More generally, by anticipating future changes in the “fundamentals” and translating them into current stock prices, speculators reward even long-term investors, the kind whom most people praise (as opposed to the short-term, quick-buck speculators). For example, if an institutional investor thinks she has found a solid company that will pay high dividends and will be around for at least 20 years, it is speculators who will help keep the day-to-day stock price from straying too far out of line with these long-term facts. If a financial panic sets in and shareholders are dumping stocks across the board, it is speculators who will staunch the bleeding and swoop in to pick up “deals” at fire-sale prices.

This shows that speculators provide liquidity to the stock market and make it more lucrative for other, long-term investors to do their homework and put some of their savings into corporations they believe have a solid future. A major risk of such an investment is illiquidity — that the investor may have to sell under duress and accept a much lower price than she could get if she only had more time — but speculators mitigate this risk. If the price gets well below “what the stock is really worth,” then that’s exactly when a speculator has an incentive to swoop in and buy.

[italics original]

 

This is from Austrian economics Professor Robert Murphy at the Laissez Faire Books.

Quote of the Day: The Ethics of Speculation and Natural Calamities

Many of the same people who today publicly encourage us to speculate (“Make sure your family has ample supplies of batteries!”) are among the loudest critics of speculation at other times and in other markets.

But in fact the oil speculator who, say, buys oil today in anticipation of oil becoming more scarce tomorrow does just what a consumer does today in a supermarket in anticipation of a disruptive storm: both persons usefully transfer resources across time.  They both stock up on resources that are today relatively abundant in order to preserve these resources for consumption at a time when they are relatively more scarce (and, hence, more precious).  Both persons transfer resources from today – when the consumption of any one bottle of water or gallon of gasoline provides relatively less benefit – to tomorrow when the consumption of that same bottle of water or gallon of gasoline will provide relatively more benefit.

Anticipating the future and taking actions to allocate goods and services from times of relative abundance to times of relatively greater scarcity is an immensely useful activity. And we all perform such speculation whether or not we are popularly identified as “speculators.”

This is from Professor Donald Boudreaux at the Café Hayek exposing the populist schizophrenic ‘moralistic’ concept of “speculation”.

Peddling “morality” through emotions has been popular even if they emanate from wrong premises and self contradictory logic. The fact is that speculation is all about acting in anticipation of the future. Different circumstances (emergency or not) under which people “speculate”  hardly does justify a moral color or distinction.

This applies to the stock markets as well.

Btw, my phone line and dsl got busted since yesterday. Internet access has been on-and-off, so I might be low on posting.