``In all countries and all civilizations, two commodities have been dominant whenever they were available to compete as moneys with other commodities: gold and silver. At first, gold and silver were highly prized only for their luster and ornamental value. They were always in great demand. Second, they were always relatively scarce, and hence valuable per unit of weight. And for that reason they were portable as well. They were also divisible, and could be sliced into thin segments without losing their pro rata value. Finally, silver or gold were blended with small amounts of alloy to harden them, and since they did not corrode, they would last almost forever. Thus, because gold and silver are supremely "moneylike" commodities, they are selected by markets as money if they are available. Proponents of the gold standard do not suffer from a mysterious "gold fetish." They simply recognize that gold has always been selected by the market as money throughout history.”-Murray N. Rothbard
Aside from the lessons of how to treat bullmarkets, there are two factors to ascertain or discover from gold’s rise:
One: To identify bullmarkets pertinent to gold’s actions and
Second: The possible implications of the gold’s resurgence to domestic gold and metal mining related issues.
The Relevance Of Gold-ASEAN Bull Markets
The Phisix and most of Asian stock markets are in a bullmarket. That has been a mantra of ours for the longest time.
In the fullness of time, perhaps the 2008 US housing bubble crisis will be portrayed as an intermission to the current phase of the bullmarket cycle.
No, relative economic success isn’t the main force that will fuel this boom, although this will be the “rationalization” or “justification” which mainstream will obviously utilize.
Instead what will drive this boom is the global bubble cycle (or what can be described as the Austrian Business cycle) that continually plagues the present state of the markets. Such cycles signify as the consequences of the world inflationism or the mainstream’s “central banking-fractional reserve-deficit spending” policy framework.
Since money isn’t neutral and where collective money printing would impact relative assets relatively, the likely magnet for the tsunami of “counterfeit” money (money from thin air and are unbacked by real savings) are sectors or nations that has eluded from developing bubble conditions during the last bubble cycle. In other words, where the supply side hasn’t generated excess capacity or malinvestments, “speculative” money is likely to flow or get funnelled into these focal areas.
They will be embraced as a surge in domestic consumption, swelling middle class, wealth transfer, demographic dividends, urbanization and alot of many other pretexts for a boom, but eventually like all bubble cycle most of these will be exposed as tomfoolery or a scam. That’s because the forces that would underpin such booms will likely be characterized by ballooning domestic credit, in households or corporate or both, and by leveraged international money flows.
Though, of course, one big factor which we cheer of is the broadening of economic freedom in many emerging markets, as seen by growing globalization of trade, investments and labor.
However, economic freedom is diametrically opposed to inflationism. Hence, two forces are fiercely counteracting or grinding upon each other. And economic freedom would have to endure from the ordeals of the volatility elicited from the falsified pricing mechanism in the marketplace derived from the current collective interventionist policies. Remember, all current actions have future consequences. Economic freedom thus is a long term proposition in the face of the adversarial forces of hidden taxation.
And it would be an irony to say that rising gold prices seem to be a “boon” to stock markets and other financial assets or the economy. That’s because rising gold prices exhibits the pathology of the endemic nature of the political agents to debase currency for political goals. The reason why rising gold prices appears as a benediction for the markets today is due to the “sweetspot” of inflation[1]- as seen by low interest rates and tolerable instances of inflation.
As Friedrich August von Hayek explained, (bold highlights mine)
``Now the chief effect of inflation which makes it at first generally welcome to business is precisely that prices of products turn out to be higher in general than foreseen. It is this which produces the general state of euphoria, a false sense of wellbeing, in which everybody seems to prosper. Those who without inflation would have made high profits make still higher ones. Those who would have made normal profits make unusually high ones. And not only businesses which were near failure but even some which ought to fail are kept above water by the unexpected boom. There is a general excess of demand over supply-all is saleable and everybody can continue what he had been doing. It is this seemingly blessed state in which there are more jobs than applicants which Lord Beveridge defined as the state of full employment-never understanding that the shrinking value of his pension of which he so bitterly complained in old age was the inevitable consequence of his own recommendations having been followed.[2]”
ASEAN’s Bullish Momentum
This welcome phase can vividly be seen in Figure 2.
Figure 2: Bloomberg[3]: Blossoming Bull Markets In ASEAN?
For major ASEAN nations, the marketplace seems ripe for a raging bull.
Indonesia’s Jakarta Composite Index (green line) has already transcended its 2008 high (!!), while the Philippine Phisix (yellow line), Malaysia’s KLCI (red line) and Thailand’s SET (orange line) are all within spitting distance.
If all four benchmarks manage to surpass their 2008 highs, then I’d presume that the region’s bubble cycle could only accelerate.
And following the recent market stresses within the EU zone where the European Central Bank (ECB) has already reactivated their own version of quantitative easing, coupled with the soon to be operational European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF), a combined €750 loan facility from the (€440 billion) EPSF, the IMF (€ 250 billion) and the European Financial Stabilization Mechanism (€ 60 billion), aimed at “providing financial assistance to Eurozone states in difficulty”[4], monetary conditions among major developed economies are likely to be very accommodative for an extended period especially in the light of Asian conditions.
And such disparate circumstances are likely to engender and amplify arbitrage or carry trade opportunities.
In the Philippine Phisix, market internals appear to be suggestive a looming major upside thrust (see figure 4)
Figure 4: PSE: Phisix and Advance-Decline Spread
The Advance-Decline spread (lower window) which is the daily tally of advancing issues less declining issues or a measure of market breadth or sentiment seems to be on the mend as the Phisix approaches its 29-month resistance levels (Upper window).
If the Phisix is to successfully breach the present resistance levels at about 3,350, we are likely to see a tight advance decline spread similar to the March-April pattern.
And if the present momentum extends, it won’t be far fetch that a test of the 2007 high at the 3,800 level will be the next topic of our discussion.
Meanwhile, the other major force, which we earlier we pointed out[5], is the potential ‘sustained’ rally in the Euro-US Dollar.
Philippine Mining Index Due For Yearend Fireworks
The other area which is likely to benefit from rising Gold prices is none other than the mining issues (see figure 5).
Figure 5 stockcharts.com: Gold and Global Mining Stocks
As gold has reached a new milestone, the benchmark of global mining stocks continue to trail or lag.
Of course, not all mining companies are created equal. And that’s the reason why I chose the Dow Jones US Mining (DJUSMG) and S&P/TSX Global Mining Index (SPTGM) to compare with gold. The activities of the general mining issues should smooth out the activities of gold miners (lowest pane; DJAPRT Dow Jones-UBS Precious Metals Total Return Index[6])
Dow Jones US Mining represents select US based gold and coal stocks[7] while the S&P/TSX Global Mining Index[8] is a global bellwether of Aluminium, Diversified Metals, Gold and Precious Metals and Coal and Consumable fuels. Both indices, while lagging, appear to be advancing. If the past will reprise, then the component issues of both benchmarks are going to do alot of serious catching up. But again, the performances of coal, industrial metals and others haven’t matched the performance of gold miners. Yet if we are right and eventually inflation accelerates then all these will rise, but the degree of increases will likely be different.
How should these apply to the local mining index?
The Philippine mining index is essentially a gold mining index with about two-thirds of the index weightings based on gold miners. The balance is distributed between coal (Semirara about 14% of the index as of Friday’s close), industrial metals (NIHao Mineral Resources 3.2%, Geograce 3.4%, and Atlas Consolidated 9.43%-Atlas is most diversified since it has also gold and silver) and oil (Oriental Petroleum 3.13%).
Figure 6: Philippine Mining Index And GOX
This suggests that like Dow Jones US Mining, the local mining issues appear to be far underperforming both Global diversified mining (as shown above) and conspicuously the gold miners see figure 6. Year to date, the local mining index is down 17.54% even as the Dow Jones Mining is up 3.07%.
Meanwhile, another US gold miner index, the CBOE Gold Index (gold line) seems hardly correlated with our local index or with gold related mining issues within the index. The GOX is up 10.6% on year to date.
The chart above consists of the top 5 mining issues in terms of capitalization, particularly Philex (red line), Semirara (green), Lepanto (orange), Atlas (black) and Manila Mining (violet). Since Philex made a spectacular nearly fourfold rise late last year, the Philippine Mining appears to be more inclined to reflect on Philex’s movements, given that Philex has about 43% of the index market cap.
Nevertheless, while there is no clear relationship between the US GOX and local mines to the upside, they have almost been as one to the downside during the Lehman collapse in 2008.
However one interesting observation is that the gist of the runs of many mining issues seems to occur during the last semester of the year, in 2006-2007 and in 2009. Of course this excludes the shock of 2008.
Hence, it is my impression that given gold’s recent fresh highs, combined with other factors mentioned above, along with seasonal and rotational effects, my next bet is that the far oversold mining index is likely to make a dramatic encore by the yearend.
[1] See Inflation’s Sweet Spot Augur For A Gold Breakout And Global Equity Market Rally, February 28, 2008
[2] Hayek, Friedrich August Can We Still Avoid Inflation? The Austrian Theory of the Trade Cycle
[3] Bloomberg.com, World Index
[4] Wikipedia.org, European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF)
[5] See Buy The Peso And The Phisix On Prospects Of A Euro Rally
[6] iPathETNs, Dow Jones-UBS Precious Metals Total Return Index
[7] Wikinvest.com Dow Jones US Mining
[8] Standard And Poors, S&P/TSX Global Mining Index
No comments:
Post a Comment